Posts Tagged ‘hope’

MARF announces Mesothelioma Symposium

29 May 2008 by Wendi Lewis under Events, Organizations

The Mesothelioma Applied Research Foundation (MARF) will hold its International Symposium on Malignant Mesothelioma 2008 in Washington, D.C., June 26-28. The annual event highlights the latest advances in research and treatment for patients and caregivers, offers psychosocial support to them as well as those who have lost someone to the disease, and provides significant advocacy and volunteer opportunities for those who are intent on eradicating mesothelioma.

According to Rob Grayson, director of marketing for the Meso Foundation, the event actually started as a purely scientific event, geared toward researchers and scientists, with technical presentations. However, at the time, there were no informational or educational events like it, and they found that patients, families and caregivers wanted to attend.

“Initially, these people would come and sit in on these high-level presentations by scientists, with very technical presentations. We saw the interest and our meeting has now evolved into more of a patient meeting, the scientists speak in more layman’s terms, and we’ve added programs to reach out to people who are also interested in the community of support and the activism that takes place,” Grayson said.

The advocacy element is a new piece of the symposium, added last year when the meeting coincided with debate in the Senate on the Ban Asbestos in America Act, S. 742, sponsored by Senator Patty Murray (D-WA).

“The day we lobbied, they took an administrative vote, and it passed in the Senate. So we’re going back to Washington this year,” Grayson said.

Advocacy efforts this year will include a rallying cry to the House of Representatives to move quickly to pass the legislation in the House, which bans asbestos and provides research funding for mesothelioma. Last week, the Foundation issued an action alert in support of The Bruce Vento Ban and Prevent Act of 2007 (H.R. 3339), the companion to the Senate bill. The bill includes $10 million for mesothelioma research.

“Normally we’d hold the Symposium in a different city each year, but it’s almost the same timing as last year, with the bill pending, this time in the House, so we’re back to Washington,” Grayson explained.

Those attending the Symposium can register to participate in the advocacy efforts, and the Meso Foundation will arrange for them to meet personally with their congressional delegate, and will provide a training session to help advocates prepare for the meeting.

In addition to lobbying for passage of the House bill, Symposium advocates will request that the Senate’s Defense Appropriations Subcommittee maintain, for the second year, mesothelioma’s eligibility to compete for medical research funding from the Department of Defense. In 2007, the DoD appropriated $50 million and included mesothelioma as a research priority for its Peer Reviewed Medical Research Program, effective in the 2008 budget. The Meso Foundation is working for continuing and increasing funds for research in the 2009 defense appropriations bill.

“There currently is no ban on asbestos, so companies can use it however they see fit. We’ve pretty much stopped mining here, but asbestos is still used in about 3,000 products that you could go out and buy right now. Even if we banned asbestos tomorrow, it probably won’t change the rate of sickness for the next 50 years, due to the latency period of asbestos. That’s why the funding for research is so important,” Grayson says. “Advocacy and the call for a ban on asbestos raises awareness, and raises money for research, which is what we need to deal with the illness itself,” he said.

In addition to advocacy, the Symposium again will feature an educational program, with sessions covering topics including Peritoneal Mesothelioma, Pleural Meso Surgical Options, Emerging Therapies, Optimizing Patient Care, and Scientific Advances in Meso Research. Other educational programs will provide instruction on outreach topics including volunteerism, fundraising, peer support and advocacy, to help those who want to make a difference learn how to be most effective.

A Gala Dinner will honor those people living with meso, and recognize outstanding volunteers and advocates for their hard work and dedication to raising awareness. The dinner will feature a unique guest speaker – Seventh grader Lexi Miletto, the granddaughter of Joseph Miletto, who died in 2005 of peritoneal mesothelioma.

Scholarships for Symposium registration fees, as well as for transportation and accommodations, are still available for patients, family members and caregivers who would like to attend. Contact the Meso Foundation at www.curemeso.org or call 805-563-8400 for details.

The Mesothelioma Foundation was started in 1999, by attorney Roger Worthington. Unfortunately, Grayson says, there was an initial stigma because of his association, with people suspicious the Foundation was attempting to gather clients for his firm, so he removed himself from the Board of Directors and the Foundation was re-established as a non-profit, 501(c)3 organization. Today, with 8 staff members, the organization raises $2.5 million annually and funds more than $1 million in research projects.

“Currently, most of our funding goes to seed money to help researchers who have good ideas for treatment to validate their work, and take it to the NIH to get additional funding for the next step of the research,” Grayson explained. “We hope very soon that we’ll be able to fund .”


Lung cancer advocate Atkinson U.S. Open pledge

13 May 2008 by Wendi Lewis under Events

atkinson2 150x150 Lung cancer advocate Atkinson U.S. Open pledgeLast week I helped spread the word that Lung Cancer Alliance advocate John Atkinson has been selected by Golf Digest magazine to play the U.S. Open golf course, on Father’s Day, June 15, as part of a celebrity foursome with NBC Today Show’s Matt Lauer, entertainer Justin Timberlake, and NFL star Tony Romo. He plans to use the opportunity to advocate for lung cancer awareness and research. NBC Sports will broadcast the celebrity event from 2-3 p.m. ET, where John hopes to break 100 on the tough Torrey Pines course.

John was diagnosed with stage IV lung cancer a little more than a year ago at age 38. He was selected from among 56,000 people who entered a contest sponsored by Golf Digest, the United States Golf Association and NBC Sports to play the U.S. Open Course as part of the celebrity team. You can read more of his inspiring story at Golf Digest online.

In addition to raising awareness, John and the Lung Cancer Alliance would like to use this event as an opportunity to raise funds for lung cancer research. They are encouraging people to make a donation or pledge to in John’s honor. There’s even a great idea for a “game day” event, where lung cancer awareness supporters can collect pledges and host a pledge party with family and friends. John is urging donors to consider doubling their pledge amount if he breaks 100!

Visit the Lung Cancer Alliance U.S. Open pledge page for donation information, pledge party forms, and links for help and more information.

What a GREAT opportunity to raise the profile of lung cancer awareness, and communicate to America – and beyond – what an important issue this is for national health! Watch for John in the coming weeks, as he is scheduled to appear on national news programs like NBC Nightly News, The Today Show and The Tonight Show. I’ll try to update when his appearances are scheduled.


Lung cancer survivor to play on U.S. Open course

7 May 2008 by Wendi Lewis under Events, News, People

atkinson 150x150 Lung cancer survivor to play on U.S. Open courseGolf Digest magazine announced John Atkinson, a stage IV lung cancer survivor, has been selected to play as part of a celebrity foursome at Torrey Pines, the same course played by the pros at this year’s U.S. Open. Atkinson will play with NBC Today Show host Matt Lauer, Dallas Cowboys quarterback Tony Romo, and recording artist Justin Timberlake. The event will be broadcast on NBC Sports on Sunday, June 15, from 2-3 p.m. (ET), in the hour leading into NBC’s broadcast of the final round.

Atkinson was selected from more than 56,000 entries, voted on by the magazine’s readers. Never a smoker, he was diagnosed with stage IV lung cancer a little more than a year ago at age 38. He hopes to use the golf event as an opportunity to raise awareness for lung cancer funding and research.

In a press release from the Lung Cancer Alliance, which urged its members and supporters to vote for Atkinson, he is quoted as saying, “The game of golf to me is living. I am going out there to enjoy the golf course, to play a great round and to give hope to those who are faced with life threatening illnesses. If I can beat America’s deadliest cancer, then I can definitely break 100 [at Torrey Pines]. It’s going to be a great day, an emotional day, and I can’t wait.”

Lung cancer is the nation’s leading cancer killer, taking more lives than breast, prostate and colon cancers combined.

To enter the contest, Atkinson submitted a 100-word essay describing why he could break 100 at Torrey Pines. Once being chosen as a finalist, he received more than 48,000 of the 117,000 votes cast in the first U.S. Open Contest, conducted by Golf Digest, the United States Golf Association, and NBC Sports. You can watch a video interview with Atkinson and read other features about the foursome at Golf Digest online.


Living with Meso – Charlene’s story UPDATE

6 May 2008 by Wendi Lewis under People, Research/Treatment

nccam logo 01 150x62 Living with Meso   Charlenes story UPDATEToday I received a wonderful email from Charlene Kaforey. Some of you have followed along with her story about her own fight with mesothelioma, which was published here in March and April. For those that are unfamiliar, Charlene, who just turned 49, was diagnosed with mesothelioma in June 2007.

With a stage III diagnosis, she underwent treatments from October to December of that year, and then, faced with the prospect of a pleurectomy or pneumonectomy, which would remove part or all of the affected lung, decided to try alternative medicine.

Charlene went to the ITL Alternative Cancer Treatment Clinic in Freeport, Grand Bahamas, in January 2008, where she underwent an 8-week treatment called Immuno-Augmentation Therapy (IAT). Upon returning home, she administers her own vaccines several times a day, and has been continuing a twice-daily intravenous vitamin C program with the help of a nurse friend.

She celebrated her birthday Sunday, then on Monday went for her first CT scan since beginning her alternative treatment. Charlene reports, “There was overall improvement in my scan results!! The tumor was half of what it was previously, the pleural thickening was reduced, fluid is reduced and the pleural effusion is gone. I am thrilled, and stunned. Of course, I’m still guardedly optimistic, since I do still have cancer and the results could change at any time. But this, for now, this is the best birthday present I could have gotten!”

Alternative therapies like IAT are not authorized by the American Medical Association, and there is still a lot of skepticism and caution surrounding them. Generally, medical insurance does not cover alternative medical treatments like IAT.

Treatments that are not considered conventional medicine, but that are undertaken along with traditional medical therapies, like , radiation and surgery, are called complementary. Treatments used in place of conventional medicine, like the IAT Charlene is undergoing, are called alternative medicine.

IAT, along with other complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) programs, are being studied by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM), which operates under the Department of Health and Human Services.

Patients considering complementary or alternative treatments are encouraged to thoroughly research possible risks, benefits, and scientific evidence, and to discuss alternatives with their physician.

For more information, visit the NCCAM online, in the “health” section under “be an informed consumer.” They have information on topics including what to do when considering using CAM, how to select a CAM practitioner, and paying for CAM treatment.

I will be exploring CAMs in the coming weeks, and hope to talk to physicians and alternative and complementary treatment doctors and specialists about these programs, as well as patients like Charlene who are using them. If you’ve had an experience with a CAM, leave a comment or email me and share your experience.

I am thrilled for Charlene! Happy Birthday!!


Compassionate Communications for the sick

2 May 2008 by Wendi Lewis under Events, News, Organizations

Amy Peterson of the Lung Cancer Alliance posted to the LCA message board / support group on Inspire.com yesterday to let cancer survivors know about a new program that aims to provide hope and cheer during a difficult time. The is partnering with Compassionate Communications, a company dedicated to connecting people in need of support and encouragement with people who want to reach out to them.

Compassionate Communications will operate a web site, which will be launched sometime this month, that will feature photos and information about people struggling with cancer, including mesothelioma, and other life-threatening illnesses. Visitors to the site can view profiles, and if they choose to register (for a fee of $25), they will receive five Hallmark greeting cards with pre-paid postage, to send to patients to encourage them, and other support materials. Twenty-five percent of the registration fee will benefit patient-serving organizations.

There is no charge for a patient to register his or her profile. The program operates in cooperation with Hallmark Business Expressions (a subsidiary of Hallmark Cards, Inc.).

Patients may download an “opt-in” registration form and waiver directly from the web site, or call 888-337-6416. The waiver must be completed and returned by mail or fax to Compassionate Communications, which will then provide participants with an account so they can set up their personal profile on the site. There is a place on the waiver form for patients to designate the patient-assistance organization they would like card-sender registration fees to benefit.

You may also get more information or ask questions by emailing Amy at the Lung Cancer Alliance at apearson@lungcanceralliance.org.


The inevitability of death

1 May 2008 by Wendi Lewis under People

Ok, it’s out there. I said it. . It’s not a subject that I go into with most of the people I talk to about mesothelioma. Even if we acknowledge that mesothelioma is diagnosed as a terminal disease, most of my conversations are about treatment options, support groups, awareness, and, ultimately, hope.

A couple of days ago I wrote about the closest topic I’ve seen along these lines, which still involved ways to find a silver lining in the struggle. Obviously, it’s a very necessary part of such a diagnosis. But it’s still about hope.

But today I came across an interesting essay, penned by Monica Sanford, a graduate student at the University of Nebraska-Lincoln, that is forcing me to look at another reality of mesothelioma. Its title, “Inevitability of leads to freer living,” was immediately arresting. The author jumped right in with, “I thought I should write about .” She went on to share that she has recently lost three people very close to her in fairly rapid succession – a paternal grandmother, a maternal great-grandmother, and her dear friend, Marilyn. Marilyn died of peritoneal mesothelioma at age 47.

As she ponders the very different lives and deaths of these people she loved, Monica wonders at a common thread – all knew they were nearing , two as a result of illness, the other just sensing her time was nearing an end, even sharing with her great-granddaughter just a month before her that she had walked with God, who showed her a waiting heaven.

That’s a truly unique aspect of this diagnosis. The knowledge, the clarity, the preparation for . Everyone knows they will one day die, of course, but that day is always a long way off. Illness of this kind brings it into sharp relief.

In the post I wrote a couple days ago about silver linings, most people said the one thing they could credit their disease for was giving them a sense of the value of their time on earth. That knowing their illness was diagnosed as terminal gave them often times a will to fight harder and stay longer, because they saw with new eyes all the things they really wanted before they would be ready to go.

There’s a saying, “live each day as if it was your last.” But in the everyday hustle and bustle, it’s so hard to keep that in mind.

Monica’s essay reflects on faith, traditional Christian faith like that of her great grandmother, as well as her own, different, Buddhist perspective, and observes the different ways that her family members mourn, or celebrate, or deny at a loved one’s passing.

In the end, she finds that, for her, “The one thing I have that helps me cope with in my life is not faith or family or hope. It is acceptance. is. Just like life is. Neither is good nor bad – they just are.”

But still, it hurts to let go.


Is pulmonary fibrosis linked to asbestos?

30 Apr 2008 by Wendi Lewis under Events, People

A while ago, I posted a series of stories from an interview with Rear Adm. Phil Coady (ret.) the Chairman of the Board of the Lung Cancer Alliance. In the interview, he talked about pulmonary fibrosis. Since that time, I’ve had several people wondering if pulmonary fibrosis is connected to asbestos or mesothelioma.

The American Lung Association explains that pulmonary fibrosis is also called interstitial pulmonary fibrosis or interstitial lung disease (ILD). These three terms are often used to describe the same condition.

ILD is not lung cancer; it is a chronic lung disorder. ILD involves a thickening of the lung tissue, which becomes stiff and makes breathing more difficult and demanding. ILD can take many forms, and may progress slowly or rapidly, depending on the individual and the nature of the ILD.

The Lung Association reports that the common link in ILD is that it begins with inflammation, which may affect different parts of the lung. Inflammation may lead to permanent scarring of the lung tissue, which is often called pulmonary fibrosis. The interstitum is the tissue between the lung’s air sacs. Scarring begins in this area, which lends the condition its formal name.

Known causes of pulmonary fibrosis include occupational and environmental exposures, including exposure to asbestos, which can damage the lungs and cause scarring (fibrosis).

Other possible causes include a disease called Sarcoidosis, side effects of medication, radiation, connective tissue or collagen diseases, or genetic predisposition, which is not as common. The familial form of the disease is often called familial idiopathic (of unknown origin) pulmonary fibrosis.

When I spoke with Admiral Coady, he mentioned that he did have a family history of pulmonary fibrosis. He knew that his family history, combined with his exposure to asbestos while serving in the Navy, put him at greater risk for the disease, and was vigilant about early screening. He did eventually develop the condition. Sadly, he also later developed lung cancer, although not mesothelioma.

Some ILD improves with medication if treated when inflammation occurs, and some people also need oxygen therapy as part of their treatment.

I hope this answers the questions and clears up any confusion. While pulmonary fibrosis is not related to mesothelioma, it could be considered an asbestos-related disease.


New mesothelioma drug being developed

21 Apr 2008 by Wendi Lewis under Research/Treatment

I recently posted about the progress of a new drug to treat mesothelioma, called ONCONASE, which has completed Phase IIIb and is being fast-tracked for approval in the U.S. ONCONASE already has orphan-drug status in the EU and Australia.

This week, I found a story that provides even more hope. It seems a Madison, Wisconsin-based biotech firm, Quintessence Bioscience, also has a promising mesothelioma drug in the works that operates along the same lines as ONCONASE, tagged QBI-139. The Quintessence drug is not yet in .

Both drugs target RNA in cancer cells. They are therapeutic ribonucleases (RNases), which WTN News (Wisconsin Technology News) writer Steve Clark describes as “ubiquitous enzymes that destroy RNA.” He explains that researchers including the University of Wisconsin-Madison’s Ronald Raines, “discovered that RNases from non-human species sometimes are not regulated inside human cells and can cause cell . Surprisingly, cancer cells are much more susceptible than normal cells to foreign RNases.”

The ONCONASE product is made from purified frog eggs. The Quintessence drug is 95 percent human, but still kills human cancer cells, Clark reports. Both drugs can kill a wide range of different human cancer types, he says, so its application has broad potential. The ONCONASE clinical trial data is from patients with malignant mesothelioma.

Clark reports that Quintessence is optimistic about its QBI-139 surpassing the positive results of ONCONASE. He says that frog-derived ONCONASE has been shown to cause allergic reactions in some patients, which would be mitigated in the 95 percent human-gene QBI-139. Additionally, he reports QBI-139 is less toxic than ONCONASE, which will allow it to be better tolerated by some patients in larger doses.

Currently, Clark reports, QBI-139 is being produced for use in a Phase I clinical trial, which is set to begin this summer and end sometime in 2009. It is anticipated that the trial will be held at the University of Wisconsin Carbone Cancer Center.

Read the full article at WTN News.

Steve Clark, Ph.D., is a former professor and medical researcher at the University of Wisconsin School of Medicine and Public Health, and is currently a freelance writer and consultant on biotechnology issues.


Living with Meso – Charlene’s story, Part 4

15 Apr 2008 by Wendi Lewis under People, Research/Treatment

The ITL Experience

While undergoing to treat her mesothelioma, Charlene Kaforey had time to explore her options. As a Stage III patient, she was worried about her chances for quality of life or even long-term survival if she underwent surgery.

During this time, she found information about the ITL Alternative Cancer Treatment Clinic, located in Freeport, Grand Bahama Island. After talking to patients who reported success, she decided to try this unusual route for her own treatment.

She made her first visit to the clinic January 7, 2008. Mesothelioma patients like Charlene initially complete an 8-week course of treatment, which includes daily blood tests, several injections daily of a serum designed to boost the body’s immune system so that it can fight the cancer, and intravenous vitamin C plus two shots of cancer vaccines, twice per week, she says.

The blood work is to monitor the body for responsiveness to the treatment in order to fine tune it to the patient and set up an ongoing course that is administered by the patients themselves after leaving the clinic, Charlene says. Treatment at ITL is a process that lasts for the rest of your life, she explains.

Now back home in New York, she administers her own shots eight to 12 times per day. She also is continuing the intravenous vitamin C at home, although she says that is optional. She also needed to complete 5 of the 12 weeks of the cancer vaccines at home. Patients return to the clinic every four months for two weeks at a time for re-evaluation and adjustments to their serum regimen. Charlene is scheduled to return in June.

“What they tell you at ITL is that it will not necessarily make the cancer you have go away, but will hopefully prevent it from spreading any further,” Charlene said. “So if they can do that, and give me six years, that would be wonderful. That would be six quality years instead of two miserable years.”

Patients considering ITL need to know that because the facility is considered alternative medicine, it is not accredited by the American Medical Association or other governing boards of that type, and some insurance companies will not cover the cost of treatments.

ITL requires payment at time of services, which, according to the clinic’s web site, for Immuno Augmentive Therapy (IAT) of the kind Charlene receives, run around $7,500 for the first four weeks and about $700 per week thereafter. That cost does not include the vitamin C IV’s or the vaccines. Patients also must cover the costs to travel to the facility, and for accommodations during their eight weeks of treatment.

“Everyone has had different experiences [with insurance],” Charlene said. “I submitted my bills to my insurance company and I’ll just see what they do. Some people get partial payment, some insurance pays nothing,” she says. “But what’s your life worth to you?”

In addition to the financial challenge, there also is the issue of travel and time away from family. Charlene was lucky; she had different family members with her throughout her 8-week stay. They became as much a part of daily clinic life as she did.

“Seeking treatment at the clinic definitely involves family decisions. The cost is a major consideration and so is the time away from home. While the cost is much less than the approximately $200,000 price tag involved with the surgery/chemo/radiation regime, insurance will pay for those debilitating treatments. Plus, knowing you may have limited time remaining, do you want to leave family and friends for 2 months,” Charlene said. “It is a really individual decision. You have to look realistically at what your own choices are and what you need to do for yourself and your family. We viewed this as an investment of time and financial resources for the long term. Two months away is worth it if I get 4-6 more years with my family.”

A big part of Charlene’s experience at ITL was meeting other mesothelioma patients, as well as people with other types of cancer, and sharing stories. Her last week at the clinic, she said there were seven mesothelioma patients there, all around the same age – mostly women in their 40s and 50s, with whom she felt a real connection.

“You talk to real-life people who are there, who are surviving and living quality lives after their doctors had told them there was no hope. The stories are so different and so amazing, and yet you share so much because you’re all going through this. It gives you hope to meet patients who have survived 28, 20 ,12 or even 4 years after being given a sentence,” Charlene said.

That connection with other patients has led Charlene to explore forming an outreach and support group where she lives, in Rochester, New York, where she plans to work for fund raising for a cure and to raise awareness of mesothelioma.

Alternative medicine is controversial. Its results often do not have a long history of documentation. People who choose this route understand that they are stepping out into largely uncharted waters.

Charlene is happy to share her story with others who are facing mesothelioma in their own lives, either as a patient or as a family member of someone with meso.

If you would like to talk with Charlene, please email wendi@mymeso.org and I will be happy to forward your information to her.


The mental toll of mesothelioma

14 Apr 2008 by Wendi Lewis under Research/Treatment

The physical result of mesothelioma and asbestos disease are often all-too evident. People wracked with pain, coughing, unable to catch their breath. But what about the mental toll of this disease?

Perhaps one of the most interesting presentations at the recent Conference in Detroit, at least to me, was that of Rebecca J. W. Cline, PhD, a senior scientist in Communication and Behavioral Oncology for the Karmanos Cancer Institute and Associate Professor of Family Medicine at Wayne State University.

Dr. Cline recently conducted a community-based focus group investigation in Libby, Montana, on psychosocial issues related to vermiculite/asbestos exposure. She also is currently leading a related population-based survey investigating that community.

She describes asbestos related disease as a “slow-motion technological disaster,” in which community and social responses have a great deal to do with how people fare, mentally and socially.

The basic definition of a technological disaster is a “catastrophic event caused by humans that results in the toxic contamination of the environment.” This includes asbestos contamination, as in Libby, resulting from decades of vermiculite mining, hence “slow moving,” as well as things like oil spills, which can devastate an area fairly quickly.

Libby is the epicenter of what Dr. Cline calls “the worst environmental disaster in the United States,” with multiple generations affected. She examined in particular how stigma associated with asbestos disease can have an impact on what people do.

Dr. Cline said there are two possible responses to technological disaster – the emergence of an altruistic community, or a community in conflict. The latter, she said, is common where there is human culpability, and it was the result in Libby.

The Libby study, conducted in 2006, included focus groups and some individual interviews with adults who lived and worked in the Libby area for at least the past five years. Interview subjects included people with connections to the mine, people with no connections to the mine, people affected by asbestos disease personally, people with family affected by the disease, and people with no disease in family or person.

She found that people fell into three categories – early believers, those who immediately understood the connection of vermiculite to what was happening to the town; late believers, those who initially resisted the idea that the mine made people sick; and those in denial or conflicted, who still did not or would not believe the mine was responsible.

Dr. Cline found that there was a great deal of stigma attached to asbestos-related disease, which created a barrier to social support. People with mesothelioma or other asbestos-related diseases were often afraid to talk about it, she said, even to close friends.

She said that the stigma came from a variety of sources. Conflicts included concerns about the economic disaster that the loss of the mine signified for the town, for which it was the main industry and source of jobs and security. People feared that if the mine were blamed for illness and deaths in the community there would be a decline in property values, loss of jobs, and a lost way of life.

As a part or a result of that, conflict also grew from a concern about what was the truth. There was a suspicion among neighbors that people claiming illnesses were phony, money-grubbing, greedy or opportunistic, making up illnesses to get a part of a financial settlement from the mining company.

People suffering from asbestos disease personally or within their family were afraid to talk about it out of fear that they would be ostracized and shunned by their neighbors and their community.

Dr. Cline told the story of two women, best friends for years, who bumped into each other in the Center for Asbestos Related Disease, which had been established in Libby to test, diagnose and treat patients. “What are you doing here?” one whispered. “I have the asbestos,” the other whispered back. “Me too,” came the whispered response. Best friends, but afraid at the core to admit to having asbestos disease.

On top of this, people who are ill or whose family members are ill fear the health and medical disaster itself, which was already upon them. They said they felt a lack of hope for survival, not just for themselves or their immediate family, but for generations.

Some of those in denial, or conflicted, still refuse to be tested for asbestos disease. They don’t want to know, Dr. Cline says, or they do not believe the mine could harm them.

There appears to be one universal in Libby.

“Across the groups, people felt like the community as a whole had been stigmatized, that everyone ‘knew about Libby’ and it had been given a bad reputation,” Dr. Cline said.

In addition to the physical toll, the mental toll of asbestos disease in Libby has been incalculable, she said.